news and blogs

When we think about security threats, we usually picture hackers behind a computer, or burglars breaking in late at night. What if we told you that a significant percentage of security incidents originate from inside an organization?

Insider risk refers to the potential for trusted individuals (employees, contractors, or even partners) to abuse their access and cause harm to a business. This harm can take many forms:

• Theft of inventory or cash
• Leaking confidential information
• Tampering with systems or equipment
• Sabotaging operations
• Negligent behavior that creates vulnerabilities

While large corporations typically employ teams and technology dedicated to identifying these risks, small and midsize businesses (SMBs) operate with tighter margins and smaller teams. They usually have less formal security policies as well, making them uniquely vulnerable to insider incidents.

In our previous article on the MICE model, we explored what motivates insiders to betray trust—Money, Ideology, Coercion, and Ego. Those motivations are only part of the story. The other side of insider risk is opportunity.

Opportunity is the Trigger in Insider Threats

When examining insider risk, businesses can look for warning signs in their employees. That might include dissatisfaction, or erratic behavior. No matter the case, opportunity is the critical trigger, because it creates temptation.

A trusted employee may never consider stealing inventory, until they realize no one is checking the storage logs. A cashier may never think about pocketing cash, until they realize the safe is rarely audited, and the manager never checks the totals.

For SMBs, unintentional gaps in process or oversight are usually what open that door. That’s why reducing insider risk isn’t just about identifying malicious intent. Instead, we work on creating systems that remove the possibility of wrongdoing by closing procedural gaps and increasing accountability across the entire environment.

Building a Security Culture That Reduces Insider Opportunities

Your physical environment and procedures matter, but they must be reinforced by a strong security culture. Without it, even the best policies can break down. Here’s how to foster a workplace culture that naturally resists insider risk.

1. Start With the Problem

Instead of assuming bad intentions, recognize that people typically act based on what they can get away with. Most theft or misconduct is not deeply premeditated, but it’s a reaction to weak controls and unclear expectations. Fix the process, and you reduce the risk.

2. Normalize Controls

Employees shouldn’t feel like controls are targeting them personally. Reinforce that procedures like bag checks, access logging, or two-person verification are standard for everyone, including leadership. This removes stigma and builds compliance.

3. Build Simple, Repeatable Systems

Complicated systems fail because they’re hard to follow. Help staff understand and follow correct procedures with easy-to-understand documentation. If someone is unsure what to do, they’re more likely to skip a step, or invent their own.

4. Separation of Duties

Never allow one employee to control an entire high-risk process from start to finish. For example:

• One employee counts cash, another verifies it
• One person receives inventory, another logs it into the system

This built-in oversight adds accountability without creating a culture of mistrust.

5. Reduce Opportunity Through Environment Design

Your physical layout can deter misconduct:

• Keep valuable stock in locked, camera-monitored areas
• Use glass office doors or open spaces for sensitive tasks
• Position registers or safes in high-visibility zones

People are less likely to take unauthorized actions when they know they can be seen. Design with visibility in mind, not just aesthetics.

6. Train New Employees From Day One

For SMBs, security might be treated as something employees “pick up” over time. Incorporate access control policies, reporting channels, and code-of-conduct expectations into onboarding instead. When expectations are clear early, they become part of the normal routine.

7. Create Safe Reporting Channels

Some employees may see issues but fear being labeled a troublemaker. Make it safe and easy for them to speak up:

• Anonymous suggestion boxes or hotlines
• Private check-ins with supervisors
• Non-retaliation policies for good-faith reports

A culture that encourages reporting is far more resilient than one that discourages transparency.

8. Perform Regular Non-Punitive Audits

Audits are essential, not just to catch theft, but to verify that procedures are being followed. Emphasize that audits are about improving processes, not blaming individuals. This creates a proactive environment where problems are addressed early.

9. Use Technology Wisely

Start small and scale as needed:

• Digital access logs and PINs instead of shared keys
• Cloud-based inventory tracking
• Entry-point cameras or smart safes with audit trails

Technology should enhance (not replace) human oversight.

10. Lead By Example

If leadership shortcuts on security measures, employees will follow. Owners and managers must model ideal behavior, from badge use and access protocols to timekeeping and policy adherence. Culture flows from the top down.

SMB Insider Risk Reduction Checklist

Most insider risks can be prevented with a combination of practical controls, cultural reinforcement, and professional assessment. Use the following checklist to assess your current controls and identify where gaps may exist in your business operations:

• Written procedures for cash handling, inventory, and access control
• Opening/closing checklists in place and used daily
• Key or PIN access log maintained and reviewed regularly
• Storage rooms locked during business hours
• High‑value assets stored in secured, monitored areas
• Security cameras placed at entrances, cash points, and storage areas
• Two‑person rule enforced for cash counting and safe access
• Weekly inventory spot checks performed and documented
• Employee onboarding includes security expectations and training
• Employees encouraged and empowered to report suspicious activity
• Owner/manager consistently models expected security behavior

Each of these measures is low-cost and scalable but can drastically reduce the likelihood of internal theft, misuse, or negligence.

If you can’t confidently check off most of these items, it may be time to assess your current practices more thoroughly. Safe Haven Risk Management offers comprehensive Security Vulnerability Assessments designed to uncover weaknesses and recommend realistic, sustainable solutions for SMBs. We offer practical recommendations that fit your business model, environment, and budget so that you can take action without disrupting your operations.

Proactive Protection with Safe Haven Risk Management

Insider risk is a threat to your finances, but it’s also a threat to your brand, employee trust, and your long-term viability. At Safe Haven Risk Management, we help SMBs turn risk into resilience by offering:

• Security Vulnerability Assessments tailored to your environment
• Training programs for staff and managers on insider risk awareness
• Physical security design and access control consulting
• Custom checklists and procedures for daily operations
• Ongoing support to keep your risk posture strong as your business evolves

Whether you’ve experienced an incident in the past or simply want peace of mind, we’re here to help you build a workplace that’s both secure and productive.

Let’s Take Action Today
If you found gaps in your checklist or recognized any of the cultural pitfalls we outlined, reach out to Safe Haven Risk Management for a free consultation and learn how we can support your organization in building a resilient, risk-aware environment—one control, one culture shift, and one secure step at a time.